The war in Afghanistan is a 9 year war at this point. The war was begun on solid reasons and was executed in a manner that quickly obtained our intended result, expelling the Taliban government and destroying Al-Queada’s ability to function. We then ignored, neglected and squandered our chance at rebuilding a country that has been in a constant state of war and rebellion for 30 years.
The result is a strong Al-Queada, destabilized nuclear Pakistan and increasing death toll of American soldiers. President Obama has been in office less than 12 months but already the Afghan war is “Obama’s War.” I don’t fully support this notion but I do acknowledge that Obama is at a cross roads. Regardless of the immoral dereliction of duty that got us into this situation in the first place President Obama now has the task of fixing it. (None of the dereliction is or was the result of anything our armed forces and those serving did or did not do.)
My question now is how much do we put on Obama? He is the leader who now has to decide to escalate, maintain or stop our engagement in Afghanistan. I use the word escalate because I am not going to play word games by calling it a “surge” in an attempt to avoid any Vietnam comparison, like our last administration so successfully did.
If President Obama decides to escalate the war by increasing troops the only way this can be done is to move troops out of Iraq. I am in favor of us getting out of Iraq because Iraq country is going to fall apart, all we can do is delay the inevitable. The other way to add troops into Afghanistan is to institute a draft. I do not think the public will stand for that? Maybe I am wrong?
From what I have read and learned, simply maintaining the current 45,000 or so troop level only continues the level of neglect and improper allocation of military resources that brought us to the current situation. Ignoring things at this point is not an option because Al-Queada has regained the strength and capabilities it once had.
Stopping the war in Afghanistan is a possibility. The results would be devastating to the people of Afghanistan. Doing so is not something we have not done in the past. We did the same thing after we helped Osama Bin Laden kick out the Soviet Union and when we refused to offer air support to the Kurds and Shiites at the end of the first Iraq war.
My emotional / moral side wants us to do the right thing, my pragmatic side simply wants us to do what is best for our country. Considering I don’t think we are out of the woods with our economic troubles I flinch at the idea of dumping billions, borrowed from China, into a war my grandkids will have to deal with. What do you feel and think?
DD




